Fisking Mark Steyn
Tuesday, November 7th, 2006I have a feeling that Mark Steyn – “the one-man global content provider” – is a smart man. Of course, I’m not a mind reader, but it seems to me that Steyn sure knows what people want, and that he takes care to give it to them. Steyn is loyal to his fans, always quick to say “Europe is doomed!”, “Multiculturalism is evil!” and “The Liberal Party is bad!” in the form on long and seemingly thoughtful articles.
I admire Steyn. He is an excellent propagandist. But I can’t say I admire his fans. I mean: Why is it that these independent thinkers, the politically uncorrect, never actually care to check out Steyn’s stories? Just a tiny little bit? My theory is that they are willing to accept anything as long as it contains the idea of Europe becoming Eurabia. Anything.
But let’s get started with fisking Steyn, shall we? We will take a closer look at one of his recent prophetic articles – “The future belongs to Islam”:
#1 Stupid demography
This is about the seven-eighths below the surface — the larger forces at play in the developed world that have left Europe too enfeebled to resist its remorseless transformation into Eurabia and that call into question the future of much of the rest of the world.
The larger forces. Sounds scary, doesn’ it? It’s the demography, stupid, as Steyn would say. What he is really talking about is sperm. The larger forces threathening Europe, and the rest of the world, is sperm. It’s not just any kind of sperm, of course, it’s Muslim sperm. Here’s the kind of image you should have of Muslim sperm when you read Steyn:
Little dudes with tails. And long beards. And suicide belts. And the collected writings of Sayyid Qutb. Looking for an egg to… well, maybe not blow up, but… you get the idea.
As many of the people telling us that Europe is doomed, Steyn is a hobby demographer. And, as other hobby demographers he has discovered that Europeans have few children, and that Muslims have many. In this specific piece, he gives two – 2 – examples from the Muslim world. The Gaza Strip. And Yemen.
Anyone wonder why he does not take for instance Tunisia and Turkey? Or for that matter the most important current member of the Axis of Evil(TM), Iran?
I’ll tell you why. It’s because they make horrible examples. Turkish women have 1.92 children in average, Tunisian women 1.74. Iranian women? 1.8 children. If you put that together with Steyn’s comment on American women having 2.1 children in average, the whole point of Steyn’s article suddenly seems… well, lacking? Steyn is concerned about the demographic development in Europe, but he has failed to realise one thing. The biggest demographic revolution at this moment of history has little to do with Europe. It is happening in the socalled developing countries. In 1970, a typical woman in one of these countries bore six children. Today, the rate has tumbled to 2.7. This is true in Brazil. It is true in India. It is also true in most Muslim countries (this makes Ahmadinejad sweat – later note: If something makes Ahmadinejad sweat, it´s most likely good news. Except for global warming, that is. Global warming is bad news).
Notable exceptions? Well, there’s the Gaza Strip. And Yemen. And a couple of other countries in the Arabic peninsula.
That being said: Yes, Europe is changing. In some ways, it is becoming the new America. You remember the poem, don’t you?
Not like the brazen giant of Greek fame,
With conquering limbs astride from land to land;
Here at our sea-washed, sunset gates shall stand
A mighty woman with a torch, whose flame
Is the imprisoned lightning, and her name
Mother of Exiles. From her beacon-hand
Glows world-wide welcome; her mild eyes command
The air-bridged harbor that twin cities frame.
“Keep ancient lands, your storied pomp!” cries she
With silent lips. “Give me your tired, your poor,
Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free,
The wretched refuse of your teeming shore.
Send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to me,
I lift my lamp beside the golden door!”
This is what Europe has to live up to, and I’m not sure it is up to the challenge. Even if it is, it is hardly going to be painfree. Still, closing the borders is not really an alternative, as one look at North Korea should tell you. So, here’s the deal: An increasing number of Europeans will be Muslim. Deal with it.
#2 Muslim + Muslim + Muslim = Eurabia?
Mark Steyn has figured out that Muslims will take over the world soon. Or at least, that is what I think he is saying. Maybe what he is really saying is that we should not let Muslims take over the world. If that’s what he is trying to say, it is not really clear what he wants us to do, though, a striking feature of many of the “Doomed!”-lot.
Anyway, Muslims make up a handy group. You can put everyone in this sack. Take one colonel Gadaffi, with his weird ideological mixture of God-knows-what, and shake him together with one mulla Krekar, the infamous Kurdish islamist living in Norway. Add some “youths” as toppings, even though they probably know more about hash than about hajj.
Steyn’s example – quelle surprise, as he says – is the youths who “stumped” and “kicked” the Belgian train conductor Guido Demoor “to death”:
Three “youths” were arrested, and proved to be — quelle surprise! — of Moroccan origin. The ringleader escaped and, despite police assurances of complete confidentiality, of those 40 passengers only four came forward to speak to investigators.
I would have understood Steyn’s description if it was written months ago. But it isn’t, which makes me wonder… did Steyn even bother to look into the case after reading about it for the first time? Or did he just add it to the notebook called “Good examples for propaganda” and forget about it until retrieving the notebook from under a mountain of books on how alone America is?
No verdict has been passed and many things are not clear about what happened from press reports, but there is a number of things Steyn fail to mention.
First of all, six youths were involved, and all six of them were eventually arrested, though the term “ringleader” does not seem to fit on any of them. Several of these youths have later been released, under various conditions.
Secondly, and more importantly, Belgian media have later reported the incident differently than the initial description Steyn repeats. Here is my translation from an article in De Standaard, a leading Flemish newspaper, from the 29th of September:
[Guido Demoor] asked the youths to act calmer. When they did not listen, he [allegedly] grabbed one of them by the neck, whereupon two of the six suspects hit and kicked the victim. The four others looked upon. The youths then ran away. Demoor did not survice the incident. From the autopsy it was concluded that the victim died of a stroke, caused by agitation in combination with high blood pressure. An experts’ report that was recently added to the case it is said that a connection between the facts [of the incident] and the death can not be ruled out”.
In short, the story is not quite as the story told by Steyn. According to the above variant, mr. Demoor was not simply the victim of aggression, and he was in no way willingly beaten to death. What happened did not last long, giving few people chance to react, and according to some news reports Demoor was still alive and seemingly well when the youths left the bus. Why does Steyn leave all this out? Because it does not fit as well into the myth of the criminal immigrant kid? And allow me to digress, because sometimes I get a feeling that many think, or want to think, that 50% of Europe’s youth of Muslim origin is criminal. That’s all the boys, I assume, since the girls are too busy being suppressed. I sometimes get the feeling that the Europe described at some websites is a Europe where large crowds of Muslim kids shoot bazookas at elderly white ladies. And that it is getting worse. Every year.
I live in a city the local xenophobic party describes as on the way of becoming an Islamic state, and I can’t really relate to their fairytale. Sure, I have experienced noisy sixteen year olds (with an unhealthy interest in literature) on the bus. They were of Moroccan origin, but acted pretty much the same way as I’ve seen noisy sixteen year old Norwegians do in Norway. In fact, the city I live in, while high on Flemish crime statistics, has a relatively small crime problem, and crime is on the decrease. According to statistics the Belgian Federal Police, there are fewer rapes, fewer car thefts, fewer breaking-and-enterings and generally less crime in Belgium now than in 2002.
Don’t expect Steyn to write about that, though. It’s not what people want to hear. People want to hear that Europe is doomed.









