oyvindstrommen.be traktningar

What is Hamas infrastructure if not the ambient support of the population? Doesn’t this attack make support stronger in the long run? Can any ground operation hope to topple the regime? What will stop the attack if not world opinion, that will not think about missiles on Shderot, but a “disproportionate response” to missiles on Shderot? Come to think of it, will they not think about Gaza under siege and what brought the place to desperate poverty? How will West Bankers react when they see Hamas standing up and dying while they feel the settlements growing around them?

And how will Egyptians react? And Jordanians? And Israeli Arabs, who are spontaneously demonstrating against the attack? And the Intel board, whose $4.5 billion dollar fab is in range? How do we build a future with Palestine when we are seen through a prism of vendetta? Will not the families and widening circles around the dead hate you forever? Do not terrorists come mainly from the ranks of youth who are ashamed to have survived? Was there not another way all along, which we cannot see now?

OUR GENERALS DO not address these questions. That is not their job. They speak instead about the need for hasbara, literally “explanation,” public relations, those critical soft skills the people in the Foreign Ministry are supposed to have, but judging from the world’s reaction seem not to have in abundance, at least, not to compare with the competence of generals, proven once again.

(Sjå også bloggposten han har kalla Teaching a Lesson – Appendix.)

Spørsmåla Avishai peiker på er viktigare enn mykje av det som vert diskutert i norsk bloggosfære, eller i norsk opinion elles. Difor vil eg gjerne utfordra israelsvenane blant norske bloggarar til å både lesa og kommentera Avishai sin artikkel. Palestinavenene, også, når eg tenkjer meg om.